Is Still
Watching




Paul's Twitter Feed

Roll Tide Roll
Dedicated to University of Alabama Football and the Spirit of BEAR BRYANT. Alabama Football is BACK Roll Tide!!!!



U of A Disclaimer
The views, opinions, and conclusions expressed in this page are those of the author or organization and not necessarily those of The University of Alabama or its officers and trustees. The content of this page has not been reviewed or approved by the University of Alabama, and the author or organization is solely responsible for its content."

Click Here

T-Town Weather

COLLEGE FOOTBALL PLAYOFFS . . .To Be Or Not To Be
Posted by Tim on Tuesday February 21 2012 @ 04:49PM CST
[ Finebaum ]
COLLEGE FOOTBALL PLAYOFFS . . .
To Be Or Not To Be

Playoffs . . . We have to have Playoffs in College Football. This is being shouted throughout the college football landscapes. Timmy "the brain" Brando has been thumping the message for the past several seasons in hopes of ending the BCS. Timmy "the brain" cheers for the like of Boise State and TCU to clinch a spot in the National Championship Game in order to create chaos and mayhem for the BCS. Lately, his cause has gathered steam with the support of Gary "Ray Romano" Danielson and of all else the Commish of the Big Ten, Jim Delaney.

At the root of Timmy "the brain" and Gary "Ray Romano" is thesis the inclusion of all teams to have an opportunity to play for the championship. However noble and grand this seems on paper, it is not fair nor feasible in the scope of "Big Boy Football". On one side, the Texas, the Alabamas and the Ohio States of the NCAA are responsible for the hundreds of millions of dollars being funneled into the NCAA. Their schedules for the most part are brutal playing before packed stadiums from 75,000 to 100,000 people every weekend. TCU to their credit has stepped up and decided the best way to get a piece of the pie is to get in the kitchen and start baking. They did this by joining the Big 12. Boise State is still standing on the curb with it's hand out with its version of college football welfare. The smaller schools dummy down their schedules and are being rewarded by playing in BCS Bowl Games.

The goal of any college sport is to crown a true national champion. The BCS was created for this purpose. In this regard they have succeeded. The BCS has been in place since 1998. Prior to the formation of the BCS. The Associated Press's number one and two teams met in bowl games only 8 times in 56 seasons. Since the BCS era number one (1) has played number two (2) in twelve straight seasons. Isn't this the ultimate goal?

The Big ten proposal . . . . basically is a plus one playoff involving the top four teams with the top two teams receiving home field advantage.

For the sake of argument, let's say Boise State is number two (2), which is a very real possibility gain the sympathy support they receive every year. Alabama is ranked third (3rd) and has to travel to Idaho to play in front of 40,000 people in the dead of winter. This is after playing through a brutal SEC schedule and the SEC Title Game. How can this be fair or equitable?

Under the BCS, a loss is extremely detrimental to a team's chance to win the National Championship. This in itself forces top teams to try and win every game. In a bracket playoff scenario the top teams may pull or rest their top players or to protect them from injury, such as the case with the NFL. Under the current system with the BCS this is not likely to occur.

The addition of the plus one playoff sounds good in theory, so good that instead of being fair to the top four, let's really be fair expand the playoffs to 8 teams and from there 10 and so on. Don't fool yourselves it will happen. It has in every major sport. The NFL, MLB, NBA, college basketball and baseball and right on cue the PAC 12 Commissioner is rumored to have crafted a play-off scenario that would have an eight (8) team play-off. Strangely enough Mike Slive, the SEC Commissioner has been noticeably quiet on the subject.

If you ask one hundred (100) sportswriters what NFL teams is the best they will say the Green Bay Packers, I agree, but the Packers didn't even make it to the Super Bowl. The New York Giants gained momentum and rode that to a World's Championship.

In College Football, for the past twelve (12) years, with the exception of 2003, these have been in clear-cut number one.

Under the current format a single loss can end a team's chance at a National Championship or enhancing a team's chance with unexpected victories. This makes every game, particularly at the beginning of the season important.

This past year was a very exciting topsy-turvy year. LSU beat Oregon, and every week fans would watch Oregon climb their way back up the polls. This scenario was repeated week after week across the landscape of college football. Week after week fans were talking and breathing college football. The Alabama vs. LSU game in Tuscaloosa had the atmosphere of a championship game. Do you think the excitement would be as great with a playoff system in places? Do you think fans everywhere would be sitting on the edge of their seats, checking scores, cheering losses if there were a play-off system in place.



< BCS Championship Grades | Shane and the Crimson Tide >

More Links
  • Printer friendly version
  • Share this story

  • Join the Tide
    Put your e-mail for weekly updates on the Tide :

    To unsubscribe from list, click here and send an empty email.

    Weekly Cartoons
    Past Bad AL Cartoons


    Last 5 Comments
  • Arkansas Grades (Bama Mike)
  • Shane and the Crimson Tide (tim)
  • Shane and the Crimson Tide (DAYNA CORN OVERBY)
  • One Last One from Shane (BamaGrad77)
  • GUS MALZAHN . . . The Real Deal or a Real Dill (tim)

  • Tide Football - Roll Tide Roll - Beat Missouri - University of Alabama Football - Unofficial site for Tide News
    Copywrite 2011 TideFootball.com






    Site Map
    Weekly Cartoon , Bad Al 2013j , 2006 Schedule , 2007 Season , 2008 Schedule , 2009 Depth Chart , 2009 Iron Bowl Videos , 2009 Recruiting News , 2009 Schedule , 2009 SEC Championship Videos , 2010 Schedule , 2011 Bama Videos , 2011 Iron Bowl , 2011 Recruiting Class , 2011 Recruiting News , 2011 Roster , 2011 Schedule , 2012 Alabama Football Schedule , 2012 Depth Chart , 2012 Recruits , 2013 Alabama January Enrollees , 2013 Recruits , 2013 Schedule , 2008 Bama News , 2008 Depth Chart , Bama Rolls Over Georgia , Bama Routs Arkansas , Bama Routs Clemson , Bama Stuff , Bama Videos , Bama Vs Auburn , Bama Vs Kentucky , Bama Vs Ol Miss , Bama Vs Tulane , Iron Bowl Seasons , Pounding Gators in the Dome , Rocky Bottoms , Scaling The Mountain 2 , Scaling The Mountain 3 , Scaling The Mountain , THE IRON BOWL , Tuscaloosa Weather , Vegas Odds , Wallpaper2 , Wallpaper3 , Wallpaper , A-Day 2012-1 , A-Day 2012-2 , A-Day 2012-3 , A.J. McCarron for Heisman , ALMOST PERFECTLY PROCESSED BULLDOG , Auburn Jokes , Bad Al 2013 , Bad Al 2013 Game by Game , Bad Al 2013a , Bad Al 2013b , Bad Al 2013c , Bad Al 2013d , Bad Al 2013e , Bad Al 2013f , Bad Al 2013g , Bad Al 2013h , Bad Al 2013i , Bad Al 2013j , Bad Al 2013k , Bad Al 2013l , Bad Al 2013m , Bad Al 2013n , Bad Al 2013o , Bad Al After Arkansas , Bad Al After Clemson , Bad Al After Georgia , Bad Al After Houston Game , Bad Al After Kentucky , Bad Al After LSU Game , Bad Al After Missisippi State Game , Bad Al After Monroe Game , Bad Al After Ol Miss Game , Bad Al After the Regular Season , Bad Al After Tulane , Bad Al After Utah , Bad Al Before Arkansas , Bad Al Before LS Who? , Bad Al Before LSU , Bad Al Before the Bowl , Bad Al Coming Back From Rocky Bottoms , Bad Al Going To Rocky Bottoms , Bad Al Juicing Oranges , Bad Al Poetry , Bad Al Sizing up The Gators , Bad Al Takes a Break , Bad All After Florida , Bad All After The Tennessee Massacre , Bad Al's 2009 Menu , Bad Al's Gallery , Badly Beaten Honey Badger Needs Help Getting Hom , Bama Beach , BAMA NEWS , Bama Quotes , Bama vs Florida , Bama vs LSU , Bama's Seasons , Bar-B-Q Bad Al Style , Bobby E Lowder , Brent Calloway , Bryant Denny Stadium Seating Chart , Bye Week , Camboozled , Championship Video , Coach Al , Coach Saban vs The Rest , Coach Saban's 2nd Favorite Charity , Coaches 2011 , Come On Coach 2 , Come on Nick , Division I streamlines rulebook , Dog Stomp Practice , Facts About 2008 Recruits , Famous Alabama Quotes , Finebaum Hat Trick , Finebaum The Coach , Fishing , Forum , Fresh Squeezed , Gamecock Stomp , Gamecock Stomp 2 , High Tide Mike , Independence Bowl , Ingram Won The Heisman , Iron Bowl History , Iron Bowl Results , It's a Good Thing That Elephants Don't Fly , Jesse Williams Video , Laying Stepping Stones 1 , Laying Stepping Stones 2 , LSU Digs Deep one Defense , LSU Slide Show 1 , LSU Slide Show 2 , LSU Videos , LSU2013 , Mad Hatter Turns the Table , New Bear Images , Nick Saban Being Encouraging , Nick Saban's Resume , Nittany Lions , Northern, Southern, and Tide Football , Ole Miss Defensive Seating , Oranges not Properly Processed , Past Bad AL Cartoons , Paul W. Bryant Jr. , Pound the Gators , Process Resistant Tiger , Processing Beef Jerky , PROPERLY PROCESSED TIGER , Quotes about Bama , Quotes About Nick Saban , Rashad's Night Out , Rocky Bottoms , Roster 2010 , Saban Quotes , Saban Video , Shane from Centerpoint , Shane Learns the Truth About the Help Bama Butto , Shane's Guest Book , SIGNING DAY , Slam Cam , Stadium Video , Steping on The Mad Hatter , Stomping The Commodores , The Bear Tells Shane the Rule , The Catch Photo , The Dog House is Ready , The Game That Counts , The Hog Stomp , The Honey Badger makes Bad Al Furious , The Stadium , The Woodshed , The Wrecking Crew , Tiger Ready for Processing , Tornado Slide Show , Tree Hugger Al , TUBBY WATCH! , Warmup Eagles , We Won One , Welcome Nick , What's Mean About Green? , Who's Next , Why we won against Georgia , Will we be able to RV , You Can't Hide Colonel Reb , '11 FL S HaSean Clinton-Dix ,